The Real Reason Why Led Zeppelin Won't Reunite

The answer isn't that complicated, according to Jason Bonham

December 21, 2018
Robert Plant, Jimmy Page, and John Paul Jones (L-R) of the band Led Zeppelin attend the Kennedy Center Honors reception at the White House on December 2, 2012

Photo by Brendan Hoffman/Getty Images

If there’s a rock and roll reunion that could sell out arenas around the world for multiple nights and then do it again the following year, it would involve Led Zeppelin. There are countless classic rock bands that have kept touring with much less of a roster than Robert Plant, Jimmy Page and John Paul Jones. But except for one-off appearances over the years, Led Zeppelin was done as a live band the day legendary drummer John Bonham died in 1980. And that’s exactly the point.

Related: WATCH: 8-Year-Old Drums Along to Led Zeppelin, Robert Plant Reacts

Jason Bonham, John’s son and a successful drummer in his own right, told Billboard about a conversation he once had with Plant about the future of Led Zeppelin. Around the time the band was rehearsing for one of those one-off reunions in 2007 that turned into the Celebration Day album and video, Bonham asked Plant straight-up:

“Are we gonna get the band back together?” Bonham recalled. "And he said, 'I loved your dad way too much. It's not disrespect to you; You know the stuff better than all of us, and no one else who is alive can play it like you. But it's not the same. I can't go out there and fake it. I can't be a jukebox. I can't go out there and try to do it that way." 

So there it is. Led Zeppelin won’t reunite because it wouldn’t feel right without John Bonham. That’s what the band said in 1980, and that’s what Jason Bonham is saying now. The only difference between Led Zeppelin and other bands that have “retired” is that Led Zeppelin meant it.

The 2007 reunion is worth revisiting though. The band was in top form with Jason Bonham on drums – a glimpse into what could be.